A truck approaching 250,000 miles has earned its scars. By that point, the engine, transmission, suspension, and cooling system have endured years of work. But which full-size pickup has the stronger record for surviving that kind of mileage? An October 2026 Autoblog comparison examined reliability data for the Ford F-150® and Ram 1500, with the Ram taking a narrow overall advantage. For Fremont, MI, truck shoppers, the findings deserve a closer look.
What the Reliability Numbers Actually Tell Us
Autoblog compared findings from RepairPal, Kelley Blue Book, and J.D. Power. The Ram 1500 performed better in two measurements, while the F-150® led in the third. However, these organizations measure different aspects of reliability. RepairPal examines repair frequency and severity, Kelley Blue Book incorporates owner feedback, and J.D. Power emphasizes quality and reliability experiences. None directly measures the percentage of trucks reaching 250,000 miles.
RepairPal Gives Ram the Advantage
Both pickups earn a 3.5-out-of-5 reliability rating from RepairPal, exceeding the full-size truck category average of 3.0. The difference appears in their rankings: Ram places first among 17 full-size trucks, while Ford finishes seventh. RepairPal also reports lower average annual repair and maintenance expenses for the Ram 1500. Over extended ownership, repair frequency and component durability become increasingly important, especially as suspension, cooling, and electrical systems accumulate wear
Kelley Blue Book Shows a Close Contest
Across the 2017–2026 model years examined, Kelley Blue Book consumer reliability ratings averaged 4.44 out of 5 for the Ram 1500 and 4.40 for the F-150. That's hardly a decisive victory, but it gives Ram another narrow advantage. The important consideration is model-year variation. Both manufacturers introduced different engines, transmissions, and technology during that period, making individual configurations more informative than a single average.
Where the Ford F-150 Comes Out Ahead
Ford leads in J.D. Power's quality and reliability measurements, averaging 79.3 out of 100 against Ram's 78.5. That's another remarkably close result. These scores provide insight into ownership experiences, but they don't establish which truck will survive another decade of towing and hauling. A well-maintained F-150 can easily be a better purchase than a neglected Ram, regardless of brand rankings.
Ram 1500 Engines and Suspension Matter
The Ram 1500's powertrain history offers several choices. Applicable models feature the available 5.7L HEMI® V8 producing 395 hp and 410 lbs. ft. of torque. Other configurations include the 3.6L Pentastar® V6 and newer 3.0L Hurricane twin-turbo inline-six engines. Many Ram 1500 models also use coil-spring rear suspension, contributing to comfortable road manners. Available air suspension adds adjustable ride height, although additional mechanical complexity deserves consideration when evaluating older trucks.
The Real Secret to Reaching 250K Miles
Maintenance history can outweigh the badge on the grille. Consistent fluid changes, cooling-system inspections, transmission servicing, and prompt repairs help preserve a truck's mechanical condition. Before purchasing a high-mileage pickup, examine service records, check recalls, and arrange an independent mechanical inspection. Pay particular attention to drivetrain operation, suspension wear, leaks, and evidence of demanding towing use.
Explore Ram 1500 Trucks in Fremont, MI
The Ram 1500 earns a slight statistical advantage, but neither pickup receives a guaranteed ticket to 250,000 miles. Vehicle condition and maintenance remain decisive. Visit Deur-Speet Motors Fremont CDJR in Fremont, MI, to explore available Ram trucks, compare configurations, and schedule a test drive online today.


